When I was asked by Cicerone to review the eighth and final
Lakeland Fellranger guide by Mark Richards, I jumped at the chance. Over the
last four years, since I first discovered this series, I have devoured each one
with delight and had high hopes (and therefore expectations) of this one.
“Lakeland Fellranger - The Far Eastern Fells” is described
as “The complete guide for walkers and explorers of the Lakeland fells”. A bold
statement, but is it true?
The Far Eastern Fells |
The author’s energy and passion come through in the text along with his knowledge of the fells and their history, with interesting insights. Perhaps most strikingly however, there are a series of four hand drawn panoramas of the views from the summit of each fell covered in the book, showing the shape and names of all the surrounding fells. This must have been a painstaking task but it adds real value, especially for those less familiar with the fells.
There are colour photos throughout that really capture the
beauty of the Lakeland fells in every season (although the author seems to have
been fortunate to avoid too much grey cloud!) and at the beginning, a useful
list of grid references for each starting point and information on safety on
the fells.
So with all that in mind, I would say that “The Far Eastern
Fells” can lay claim to being a “complete guide”. This does of course mean that
at over 330 pages, it is quite a weighty volume so is more for planning and reference
than adding to your rucksack (although I have also done that with previous
volumes).
With the completion of volume eight of Lakeland Fellranger,
Mark Richards has, in my view, provided a comprehensive series of guides to the Lakeland
fells not seen since Wainwright. The whole series covers 227 fells (Wainwright
covered 214). Mark Richards demotes five Wainwright fells (I will not spoil the
books by saying which ones, but for those who feel the same way about Mungrisdale
Common as I do, you will enjoy reading them all the more) and added new ones
that Wainwright did not cover.
I am a fan of the Wainwright guides and probably always will
be but the time was and is right for another set of guides that are fresher and
can appeal to a whole new audience. This Fellranger set, culminating with the
Far Eastern Fells, in my view is just that and could easily last us the next
fifty years. Will 227 become the new 214? Will we talk in future about climbing
the “Richard’s” rather than the “Wainwright’s”? I think the answer to that
rests with Cicerone and how they manage to keep them relevant and fresh over
the coming years....
“Lakeland Fellranger –
The Far Eastern Fells” is published by Cicerone. There is more information on www.markrichards.info including
additional photos and the summit panoramas
RRP £14.95
I think that the Wainwrights will still be the premier Lake District list but there's enough common ground that a lot of baggers will probably do both lists concurrently.
ReplyDeleteThere's been enough on the web recently to indicate that they're going to be called "the Fellrangers".
Luckily I've only got 4 left to tick - roll on August !
That's fab news - I hope you get some lovely views for your final 4. I was very lucky with my final 3 - a perfect day.
DeleteI am looking forward to climbing the additional fells in Fellranger although have done a few anyway. :-)
Thanks for this review Tanya. I got an excellent sense of what this book offers.
ReplyDeleteI particularly like the sound of the four handdrawn panoramic views of the fells taken from the summits and which name the surrounding fells. That sounds like a labour of love.
As for the 214 versus 227 issue I don't know enough to comment but a fresh view can a be a good thing.
Thank you :-)
DeleteI do think a fresh set of guides is a good thing - people can pick and choose from old and new then or use one to complement the other.
Thanks for commenting.
Tanya